Search Shop News Catalog My EdiblesNEW Contact Forum Blog

<< Back to Daleys Fruit Tree Forum

Free fruit Trees in Public Places

    39 responses

Correy starts with ...
I believe that local councils should be planting fruit trees rather then flowers, shade trees etc. If you know of a council where:

1) Town Planning Incorporates Public Fruit Trees.

2) You or friends have lobbied councils to plant fruit trees.

3) You planted fruit trees in public places yourself assuming it would be ok.

4) You tried to get a council to plant fruit trees but was rejected.

I would love to hear your experience below.

Video: Motivation from River Cottage Autumn on the topic.


* You can watch the full episode on abc iview here:
http://www.abc.net.au/iview/#/view/455675
Urban Tree Change
About the Author
Correy
Brisbane
30th October 2009 1:14am
#UserID: 2959
Reply |
Original Post was last edited: 30th October 2009 12:29pm
Ellen says...
yeah, I think it is such a waste of spaces to plant those useless gum trees, during the hot summer heat waves months it only causes those bush fires, such a hazard.

I wish my council would permit me to plant fruit trees beside those foot paths instead of making us put on turfs.
About the Author
Ellen
Smithfield
30th October 2009 4:31am
#UserID: 1339
View All Ellen's Edible Fruit Trees
Reply |
Polly says...
Maybe I'm being negative but when I drive along the roads of NSW and see untended fruit trees such as apples I wonder if this is just a reservoir for fruit fly. I agree with your proposition BUT only if they will not be a pest reservoir. It's hard enough now managing pests with the untended garden fruiting trees that remain in suburban backyards.
About the Author
Polly
Newcastle
30th October 2009 9:05am
#UserID: 1702
Reply |
HappyEarth says...
Urban food production is essential for a sustainable future.

Hey Correy, just saw this clip on abc news regarding urban food growing in Chippendale, Sydney:

http://www.abc.net.au/news/video/2009/10/29/2727866.htm

Down here in Wollongong we hoping to implement a fruit street tree planting with Wollongong city council. Ill let you know how it all goes :)

Rich
www.happyearth.com.au
About the Author
HappyEarth
Wollongong
30th October 2009 11:00am
#UserID: 2553
View All HappyEarth's Edible Fruit Trees

Reply |
Kath says...
Ellen,
I love my fruit trees but please don't under value the importance of our native species. Gum trees provide hollows for homes and are rich in nectar also providing food for entire ecosystems of native species not to mention our iconic koala. What we need is a balanced approach so we have food for all, ourselves and our native birds and animals.

Pictures - Click to enlarge

Picture: 1
  
About the Author
Kath
Cawongla
30th October 2009 11:38am
#UserID: 2
View All Kath's Edible Fruit Trees

Reply |
Ellen says...
don't get me wrong Kath, I do understand the balance and the importance of it, but there is no need for the front of my house to have 4 of them, and I am in the middle of a highway, yet 50 yards away is a little park.

Do you know what it's like with all those branches broken off when big winds come?, last time when we have one of those mini storm one got uprooted and fell on top of my car, my insurance refuse to cover for it, even though it was an act of nature.
We were not allow to trim off dead branches, and it it had overgrown into our overhead electrical wirings supplying into our house. Every time it is windy, it dangling wavy with the winds, our electricals appliances in the house flickering on and off as it goes with it. we'd call the council, and it would take 9months to a year before those folks would come down and trim some off.
I use to enjoy those morning sunlight rays piercing through my windows in the morning it warm up the house, now I don't get that any more b/c those overgrown gum trees on the foot path planted by the council had blocked it off completely .
After each rainy session we have, my front yard are covered with dead small branches, I cannot see the grass any more.
About the Author
Ellen
Smithfield
30th October 2009 12:06pm
#UserID: 1339
View All Ellen's Edible Fruit Trees
Reply |
Correy says...
Happy Earth:
Fantastic I added it to our newsletter

Which should get emailed out soon.
About the Author
Correy
Brisbane
30th October 2009 12:30pm
#UserID: 2959
Reply |
CJ says...
Hi Kath, I completely agree with you. Unfortunately our native species are quite undervalued by developers. There are a lot of trees that aren't suitable for urban areas (such as Ellen's pesky gums!) but there are many more choices that are.

The public fruit trees is an interesting concept but I would worry about maintenance. Councils (in WA at least) like as little maintenance as possible.
About the Author
CJ
Mandurah WA
30th October 2009 12:54pm
#UserID: 2533
View All CJ's Edible Fruit Trees

Reply |
Itdepends says...
Maintenance = money. How many ratepayers don't want there rates to be as little as possible?

My concerns would be the fallen fruit, diseases etc- and you'd have to be careful what you did plant. A lot of them wouldn't fruit well without irrigation during the summer (at least over here they wouldn't).
About the Author
Itdepends
 
30th October 2009 3:29pm
#UserID: 0
Reply |
J R says...
Shahtoot Mulberry is a delicious fruit-fly free fruit tree for nature strips,but it has huge long roots,so would a Daley's dwarf mulberry be better?
I planted a Shahtoot,then the council pulled it up a few weeks later.

Wicked.
About the Author
J R
 
30th October 2009 3:36pm
#UserID: 0
Reply |
Diana says...
I have seen mulberries, edible lillypillies, and rosemary planted in public spaces (uni campus and local school). There are macadamias as street trees at Mt Glorious. I have heard of wine palms, date palms, and ice cream bean as park and street trees. None of those need much maintenance or water when established, or get pests. I think arrowroot, lemongrass, bay tree, and other tough, large herbs would be OK.

Diana.
About the Author
Diana
Brisbane
30th October 2009 10:36pm
#UserID: 0
Reply |
Gus says...
We are trying to start an edible demonstration garden on campus he at uni. (La Trobe, Bendigo).

It's slowly getting there.

That's not quite the question asked, but similar.
About the Author
Gus
Bendigo
30th October 2009 10:43pm
#UserID: 2918
Reply |
paula says...
I think it is a great idea - maintenence, pests, litigation notwithstanding. :)

Byron Shire council is doing something along these lines, and so is manchester.

http://www.byron.nsw.gov.au/food-production

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1172446/The-city-thats-turning-giant-allotment-free-produce-all.html
About the Author
paula
Australia
31st October 2009 8:19am
#UserID: 2962
Reply |
Manda says...
I think this is an awesome concept... I loved the river cottage eposide about it it made me feel very inspired.
About the Author
Manda
Perth, WA
31st October 2009 5:27pm
#UserID: 0
Reply |
amanda says...
I try to have a balance in my garden - I have food plants for the birds, bees, lizards etc and food plants for us.

This is possible everywhere and I feel the biodiversity of my garden results in very few serious pest problems.
EG: I have quite a lot of bob-tails (blue tongues/stumpy tails) in my garden and they clean up most of the fallen fruit. OK - a mulberry is not native - but me and my bob-tails don't mind! :)
Nature seems to adapt and find it's own way of filling every niche, man made or not.
I would like to see more "habitats" for our fauna - which is losing precious ground every day. This can co-exist with the needs of people surely?
About the Author
amanda
Geraldton. WA
1st November 2009 10:40am
#UserID: 2309
View All amanda's Edible Fruit Trees

Reply |
Elf says...
Great idea, I'm a strong supporter of that concept.
Straggly bottlebrush street trees look super unsightly and humungous gums street trees can be dangerous. I know native trees are important and all, but koalas don't dwell in street trees, though Magpies and I'm sure other things do.
I like the idea of fruit fly resistant fruit trees, no need to make that problem worse - it's such a shame for pomes and stonefruit :(

Bushtucker trees get my vote too. I think we are tragically undereducated about our native foods. I know next to nothing.

Love the Byron plan. I stumbled on a blog from Norfolk Island recently and they are pretty much self sufficient food wise because they have very strict quarantine laws. It would be great if you could buy most of your fruit and veg from mostly local sources and learn to live with seasonal foods. It's more normal, isn't it?

I went to the local farmer's market for the first time on the weekend hoping for wads of local fruit and veg, but apart from $6 a kg apples and pears and very expensive strawberries there was hardly any f & v :( I will keep going, it might change over the seasons.

blah blah :)
About the Author
Elf
Albury
1st November 2009 5:36pm
#UserID: 2913
Reply |
Wayne says...
I'm sorry, but I'm going to be the odd one out here, I don't think fruit trees have any place in the public arena. Do you think that the fruit would ever get to ripen before the people had it stripped from the tree.

It is a shame but that's the way some people are
About the Author
Wayne
Mackay QLD
1st November 2009 7:00pm
#UserID: 338
View All Wayne's Edible Fruit Trees
Reply |
Original Post was last edited: 1st November 2009 7:04pm
anonymous says...
Yes, you are definitely.
About the Author
anonymous
Mackay
1st November 2009 8:17pm
#UserID: 0
Reply |
Julie says...
My concern is that people start off really keen, water them, feed them etc.

Then they move, or get too old, or die, and the next person isn't interested.

I see this often where I live - not in street trees, but backyards. Someone plants fruit trees, later sells the house, and the next person can't be bothered, or knows nothing about gardening. Fruit fly-infested fruit lies on the ground - you can imagine what the local orchardists think of that!

So while I think it's a lovely idea, I don't think it's practical. As it is on council land, who does the fruit belong to?

About the Author
Julie
Roleystone WA
1st November 2009 10:08pm
#UserID: 0
Reply |
Albert Einstein says...
FRUIT CITY: a living growing map of the fruit trees in public spaces in London

http://www.fruitcity.co.uk/

http://www.fruitcity.co.uk/map/

http://www.fruitcity.co.uk/species/

About the Author
Albert Einstein
Fruit Forest Lane,Fruitville
1st November 2009 10:45pm
#UserID: 0
Reply |
Simon says...
I believe that public fruit trees will cretae a fruit fly nightmare. My experience has been that nut trees and herb plantings are more productive in a public space.
About the Author
Simon
Fountaindale
2nd November 2009 9:00am
#UserID: 2970
Reply |
Wayne says...
It would be nice to have some native trees to encourage some Koalas to come visit, see how relaxed this guy is.
Pictures - Click to enlarge

Picture: 1
  
About the Author
Wayne
Mackay QLD
2nd November 2009 11:26am
#UserID: 338
View All Wayne's Edible Fruit Trees
Reply |
Kath says...
Kyogle has a little pecan plantation on the outskirts of town and during nut season it always has visitors picking up the nuts for free.
About the Author
Kath
Cawongla
2nd November 2009 3:17pm
#UserID: 2
View All Kath's Edible Fruit Trees

Reply |
Jimmy says...
Most shires in Perth specifically will not allow Macadamias as street trees due to the possibility that people will slip over on the round nuts...

Told to me by Peter Coppin.
About the Author
Jimmy
Perth
2nd November 2009 4:05pm
#UserID: 2548
View All Jimmy's Edible Fruit Trees

Reply |
Wayne says...
By memory there are a lot of nut trees in Canberra
About the Author
Wayne
Mackay QLD
2nd November 2009 4:08pm
#UserID: 338
View All Wayne's Edible Fruit Trees
Reply |
Jane says...
Macadamias need to be planted along the edges of bush parks so the nuts don't drop on the footpaths, and yet people can se them and access them if they wish. All street trees need to be planted so they are not dropping fruit, seeds, nuts, leaves onto cars or houses or making footpaths slippery: if sensible consideration for situational differences is the norm then practical solutions for everybody, could be negotiable. Forums such as this provide valuable conversations for establishing guidelines for consideration when putting forth proposals or simply planting yourself. well done folks.
About the Author
Jane
Brisbane
2nd November 2009 9:47pm
#UserID: 0
Reply |
Itdepends says...
Jane- do you work for a local council or govt organisation?
About the Author
Itdepends
 
3rd November 2009 3:05pm
#UserID: 0
Reply |
Jessica says...
I have always suggested this to my husband & we tried to think as to why the councils were NOT doing this, our reasoning was potential poisoning if passerby's ate sprayed fruit & a loss of income for growers if the street scaping became large scale. I would like to see the the 'ideal' of people picking free fruit as the walked the streets, but there are potential drawbacks.
About the Author
Jessica
 
5th November 2009 10:22am
#UserID: 0
Reply |
M Nash says...
I'm sorry (also) to be a negative voice.
But you are living in la la land.
Growing fruit trees is not going to "Save the future" Nor is it going to feed the community. Nor are the "Community Gardens"
Fruit trees need methodical care, If they are in in public domain they will become wild or infested. I dont want my rates to be hyked up to make the local dooms sayers and greenies feel all googy inside.
What we need is productive farmers IN AUSTRALIA growing our fruit and a community (Government) backing them up.
I don't have a problem for growing your own fruit trees in your own backyard, However, This comes with responsibility to ensure your lemons don't infect My lemons. Get my drift.
It is feral thinking and the cost of it should not be thrust upon the wider community to satisfy a Minority.
End rant, All good



About the Author
M Nash
Terranora
5th November 2009 11:02pm
#UserID: 2892
View All M Nash's Edible Fruit Trees
Reply |
Tropicdude says...
I have to agree with Nash, no one loves fruits and fruit trees as much as me, but its not practical to have fruit trees planted all over the city and or the "burbs", city planners usually select trees for low maintenance, and for other attributes, like how the roots grow, can they handle drought, even whether they drop leaves all at once or over a long period of time, do they tolerate pollution etc. fruit trees need pruning, fertilizers and cleaning up after.

Now on community gardens, I do like these, I do not think they will save the planet but, these gardens will only attract those that like gardening anyway, it brings people together, they can make "eye sore" areas into beautiful places. and of course the added benefit of fresh veggies and greens. I also like the idea of Urban farms ( hydroponics Aeroponics etc.) I know that not everything can be grown in the city but many things can, when you think of all the fuel used to transport veggies into the cities, it makes sense to grow these on roof tops of buildings. of course these would be commercial and profitable projects.

Who knows maybe someday we will have vertical city farms like this one:


About the Author
Tropicdude
 
6th November 2009 6:13am
#UserID: 2856
View All Tropicdude's Edible Fruit Trees
Reply |
Original Post was last edited: 6th November 2009 6:19am
Vicki says...
I like the idea in theory, but dont think it will work in the long run. It is 40 degrees C here today, and I have been flat out this week keeping my own trees and veg alive. Our government is allowing thousands of mature street trees to die due to water restrictions, so I cant see local councils putting in the money and effort to properly look after fruit trees, when they dont even look after the natives very well. The long lead time between planting and harvesting will also discourage authorities from investing in fruit trees. Of course citizens could make an effort to look after them, but people move, or dont want to use their water on public trees, or vandals (and possums) strip the trees before the fruit is ripe. Its a shame, but I dont think it's a realistic idea in this climate.
Pictures - Click to enlarge

Picture: 1
  
About the Author
Vicki
Adelaide
15th November 2009 10:59am
#UserID: 3008
View All Vicki's Edible Fruit Trees
Reply |
Rev says...
ok
so up here in NQ theres mango trees bloody everywhere
now the diffrence is between the south and the north is that theres still heaps of wildlife here
Fruitbats and parrots get the lions she or - everything
great if you want to eat fruitbats and parrots, you coul just sit on your deck with a blowgun an harvest the bounty

anyway interestingly the fruitfly isnt that bad here! noweher as bad as when i was in nthn NSW

i like the idea. but there are suitable trees and unsuitable trees for streets, and that list'll change with the areas

for example theres issues like disease, mess, spines, blah blah

if were going to have rules, they need to say who is responsible for what, and what happen if they dont maintain it

with education to give guidlines on the bst species

but not hard rules. i mean for heavens sake, councils arent even a lawful form of govt under the constitution! we cant hav them telling us what to do anymore.

ok so suggestions that ive seen work very well to follow
About the Author
Rev
North qld
25th November 2009 11:22pm
#UserID: 1806
View All Rev's Edible Fruit Trees
Reply |
Rev says...
Trees that look good, are productive
and dont cause much mess or harbour major diseases

( a major bias here for tropical plants as thats where i am, these are ones ive seen used already - except pimento and clove )

A grade

Bay trees
Pimento
Jaboticaba
Pommelo
Moringa
Santol
Agathi
Clove
Tamarind
Wine palm
Otaheite gooseberry
Jackfruit
breadfruit
Peanut tree (sterculia quadrifida)

B grade - single faults
Carry fruit fly- but are a minimal reservoir

curry leaf
Pawpaw

make a mess-

Olive
neem

or are hosts for disease for backyarders if not cared for-

Kaffir lime
Banana

IME
Mulberries def carry qld fruit fly
not seen them in shahtoot yet but M alba and M nigra definitely get struck somtimes severely

lets not forget edible landscping with perennial veggies

groundcovers
Lalot pepper - see the big ol fig at the sthn end of the esplanade, cairns with a big patch of lalot pepper - looks great
or lebanese cress
or Cuban oregano
or vegetable fern
in a wet spot i often see gotu kola and brahmi, they seem to be native up here
or just plain old taro

also
i have a bone to pick with the
pictures chosen above

the Poinciana (delonix regia) is one of the worlds mos stunning flowering trees,
it also, is a legume.
I think there is scope to not necessarily use the streets to grow food , but maybe to grow ferility.
I regularly bag up leaf fall from street trees
Ficus, neem, Acacia, Albizzia, Hibiscus etc
and they make the bulk of my bedding for a worm farm, to this i can add kitchen scraps
it makes great compost

as much as we need food garden, we also need the organic matter and nitrogen to sustain them, produced close as possible

i do like that many many street trees her are Ficus and tree legumes. Its gives us lots of good leaf litter to use

so dont bag non-fruit street trees, rater let look constructivley at how to reintegrate street trees into our urban ecology
About the Author
Rev
North qld
25th November 2009 11:52pm
#UserID: 1806
View All Rev's Edible Fruit Trees
Reply |
Sarah says...
I only have a little story to share. On 12.10.09 I and some friends parked our cars on Broughton Road, Artarmon to catch the train to the city. When returning I stopped, quite surprised to see a mulberry tree growing on the curb side (I assume this is council land?) It was about 1.5 metres high, healthy and full of green mulberries. I exclaimed to my friends what it was and how exciting it was to see it there. Interestingly, my friends said they had seen these massive trees near where they live at Marayong (near Breakfast creek) but didn't know what they were. They felt confident then to pick them once the berries were ready.
I think it is a brillant idea to plant food. I'm looking forward to reading and learning more. Sarah
About the Author
Sarah
Baulkham Hills
26th November 2009 10:43pm
#UserID: 3050
Reply |
Irena says...
I have planted an apple tree in the nature strip, as well as other trees.The Council has not objected and one opasser-by even came with equipment to prune it! The apples are enjoyed by many, even by the dogs being walked.
I have forwarded your newsletter to our council member in charge of Parks and Recreation.
About the Author
Irena
Lunceston,Tamania
27th November 2009 11:10am
#UserID: 3051
Reply |
Itdepends says...
Mind you- isn't the apple isle free of fruit fly and codling moth?- two of the pests that might otherwise breed in an un treated fruiting street tree?
About the Author
Itdepends
 
29th November 2009 11:09pm
#UserID: 0
Reply |
clare says...
I am very interested in this - after seeing the River Cottage episode - its a great idea. The only trouble is - the fruit will get taken by the birds unless netted - so is it then a waste of effort?
Clare
About the Author
clare
wa
2nd December 2009 12:34pm
#UserID: 3063
Reply |
PeterC says...
There have been some good comments so far on both sides. What we need is a blend of suitable trees, both those that help our native environment and those that we can use.
High maintenance fruit trees or those that harbour exotic pests or diseases should be avoided (& that varies from state to state). In WA there are many useable tree species - macadamia, pecan, mulberry, Eureka lemon, etc.
There is one council in Perth who have banned macadamias from verges, but who are still planting Queensland box (Lophostemon confertus) - how silly is that? So Box seeds are OK but macadamias aren't? What about all Eucalyt seeds (gumnuts)?
I think the answer is for all local government bodies to foster community food gardens that include fruit trees.
About the Author
PeterC
Perth
2nd December 2009 6:35pm
#UserID: 2860
Reply |
Wayne says...
Peter, our local council has Tamrind trees on some public areas, I don't know if they would suit everywhere and I don't know if most people know what they are
About the Author
Wayne
Mackay QLD
2nd December 2009 8:52pm
#UserID: 338
View All Wayne's Edible Fruit Trees
Reply |
Roger says...
Hi all, some - mostly all good comments.Most of the fruit from my 2 to 3 thousand tropical fruit trees is eaten by the flying foxes and my few cows eat what falls, not such a big loss as the return is pretty minimal all things taken into account. My biggest campaign has been to slow up the killing of coconut trees in public places and even encouraging the planting of more - see one of my letter's to the editor attached- in between tripping around the pacific and Cape York Peninsula encouraging locals to plant and maintain more fruit trees. Probably the biggest issue is to select the best tree/plant for the location or modify the location to suit the plant. Best done by small groups of like minded people with access to good decision making information.
It is mango season up here and public place-mango trees are carpeted with fallen half eaten fruit - birds and flying foxes again. Good shade trees for the rest of the year.Our local council has been very active in planting various edible fruit trees but unfortunately when the cyclones come and damage them it is easier to chop them out. I could go on but a last point for today was the great crops of roadside guava during the papaya fruit fly eradication years up here in coastal Far north Queensland.
Pictures - Click to enlarge

Picture: 1
  
About the Author
Roger
Innisfail
7th December 2009 8:15pm
#UserID: 795
View All Roger's Edible Fruit Trees
Reply |

REPLY to this forum

^Email: display Name:
Location:  
Pictures: Add Another Picture
Body:
 
Remember to include a picture if possible

<< Back to Daleys Fruit Tree Forum